Reviews and Comments

astralstreeting

astralstreeting@wyrmsign.org

Joined 2 years, 3 months ago

This link opens in a pop-up window

Joanna Russ, Nicole Rudick: Joanna Russ : Novels and Stories (2023, Library of America, The, Library of America) 5 stars

Beyond compare

5 stars

I slowed down a bit with the story Picnic on Paradise and should probably read it a second time because of the stops and starts.

I wanted a second opinion so I tracked down the least annoying booktuber I could find and she also had a difficult time with the story. However, her take was that Alyx was experiencing estrangement and the reader is meant to follow through this experience while the character adapts (to being on a new world, with hypnotic language training). The booktuber had to pause the review because she was moved to emotion by the subtlety of Joanna's technique in guiding the reader through this. I didn't really experience this but one day I will re-read the story with it in mind.

Every other story deeply affected me. The Second Inquisition was a nice gift after struggling with Picnic on Paradise.

Alan Tansman: Japanese Literature (2021, Oxford University Press, Incorporated) 5 stars

Broadened my horizons

5 stars

I was first exposed to Japanese literature and literary fiction in my late teens through Yukio Mishima. I read him fairly uncritically at that age. I found the politics silly and I thought he was doing theatre or that his death was a fulfillment of a sexual fantasy. It did make me want to live more in my body and less in my imagination. Reading a queer writer at this age also helped me grow as a person. Though it would be hard for me to minimize the politics if I re-read his stuff now, 30 years later, especially with a better understanding of the background of his time.

Reading Japanese Literature: A Very Short Introduction has made me excited to discover many of his contemporaries and other modernist Japanese writers. There seem to be many figures who are equally fascinating and write at the same level of excellence. I …

Joanna Russ, Nicole Rudick: Joanna Russ : Novels and Stories (2023, Library of America, The, Library of America) 5 stars

The Female Man, We Who Are About To, and On Strike Against God are all extremely great 5/5 stories that are completely different asides from sharing a type of narrator that is uniquely Joanna Russ.

And if you don't know who she is, she's the angry lesbian of the new wave of science fiction, and probably a pound for pound better writer than Ursula K. Le Guin (and Ursula's one of the best...).

After the first three novellas are the Alyx stories. So far, these are light, fun adventure stories that draw on Fritz Leiber's tales about Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser in terms of style and content. Fritz Leiber is disappointing in some respects but the fact that he was in open dialogue with Joanna Russ is a point in his favor. It is nice to read these stories after We Who Are About To, which is one of …

reviewed Out by Natsuo Kirino

Natsuo Kirino: Out (2003, Kodansha International) 3 stars

After strangling her husband, Masako Katori, a middle-aged wife and mother working the night shift …

My review of Out

4 stars

The ending of this book was beyond what I can tolerate but I think it is a case of the author doing what they want to do in defiance of giving the reader what they want or expect from crime fiction -- whether it is a happy ending, a return to the norm, etc. I don't think the reader is supposed to feel a sense of peace with the ending.

Otherwise, the rest of the book is want I want from a crime novel. Shifting perspectives, with each character strongly situated in the their social and economic circumstances and how they relate to other characters. Every character and situation is very well developed before any crime happens. Police are not the central figures in it, it is the actually the "criminals". This is procedural and detailed without needing to make the police or a detective central figures that restore balance …