willowmillway reviewed Hour of the Star by Benjamin Moser
What it takes to be a star
4 stars
Am i a bad person for finding this really funny? Sure, this story has a big social question to it, but i find Macabéa's life to be a comedy more than a tragedy. If you take the ending as an example, no spoilers, it hits like a melancholic punchline. The story doesn't give any hope, so there is no tragedy possible. Our main character's primary trait isn't stupidity or ignorance or fearfulness, it's hopelessness. There is no life imaginable for her, so the ending really comes off as perfect. If nothing good ever happens to you, you have no need to fear anything. You live in hopelessness and every crumb is a feast. I'll likely have more to say about this book as time goes on.
Am i a bad person for finding this really funny? Sure, this story has a big social question to it, but i find Macabéa's life to be a comedy more than a tragedy. If you take the ending as an example, no spoilers, it hits like a melancholic punchline. The story doesn't give any hope, so there is no tragedy possible. Our main character's primary trait isn't stupidity or ignorance or fearfulness, it's hopelessness. There is no life imaginable for her, so the ending really comes off as perfect. If nothing good ever happens to you, you have no need to fear anything. You live in hopelessness and every crumb is a feast. I'll likely have more to say about this book as time goes on.